The 1898 footage from the Torres Strait Islands

Note from David Zeitlyn as 2021 Editor: this pages collates several pages accompanying the original database that discuss Haddon's original films. Some links have been updated but as much as possible I have not touched the original text. Readers are also alerted to Michael Eaton's 2010 film about Haddon 'The Masks of Mer'


In commemoration of Alfred Haddon's pioneering work in the Torres Strait, in anticipation of the forthcoming centenary of the 1898 Torres Strait expedition, and an indication of what see as the value of early ethnographic film footage for anthropological research, the items in the menu below link together some of the visual and other resources available.

The 1898 footage

It is estimated that Haddon took some 2,250 feet of film to the Torres Strait Islands, to be shot on a 35mm Newman and Guardia camera camera. From this stock some 4.5 minutes of developed footage now remain (information from Long and Laughren 1993 (extract below))

The extant footage consists of four sequences (the second sequence consists of two near-identical takes):

Stills from the sequence.

 Sequence 1  Sequence 2 
 Sequence 3  Sequence 4 

Some of the footage is available on Wikimedia


We are grateful to the University Museum of Archaeology and Anthropology, Cambridge, for permission to reproduce images from the footage. All these images are copyright Universty Museum of Archaeology and Anthropology and may not be reproduced.

The images currently being used on these pages were frame-grabbed from a VHS video tape copy of the footage. We hope in due course to replace them with higher quality frame stills taken directly from a film copy of the footage.


Long and Laughren extract

Note: the following text is an extract from an article that first appeared in Cinema Papers No.96, 1993, pp. 32-37; 59-61. It describes A.C. Haddon's film work in the Torres Strait in the context of the development of cinema in Queensland and Australia more generally. The following extract (pp. 33-36) is reproduced with kind permission of the authors.


Extract from:

Australia's first films: facts and fables

Part six: Surprising survivals from Colonial Queensland

Chris Long and Pat Laughren

First Anthropological Films

Haddon's Cambridge Expedition to Torres Strait 1898

Sir Walter Baldwin Spencer's 1901 films of Australian Aborigines are often portrayed as the pioneering effort in the field. His effort was praiseworthy, but Spencer was following a precedent set in 1898 by his colleague Alfred Cort Haddon (1855-1940) Haddon's films were the first ever taken on a field expedition.[13]

Two years after graduating from Cambridge University in 1878, Haddon was appointed Professor of Zoology at the Royal College of Sciences, and Assistant Naturalist to the Science and Art Museum in Dublin. In this capacity, Haddon spent eight months on an expedition investigating the marine zoology of Torres Strait during 1888 and 1889. There, he became fascinated by the rapidly disappearing customs and ceremonies of the Islanders, spending most of his spare time noting details for subsequent publication. Several minor papers were subsequently published, but the research was inadequate to assemble a general ethnographic work on the region.[14]

Haddon therefore assembled a team of scientists, all subsequent leaders in their specialities, to go to Torres Strait in 1898 and make a thorough study of it. They were comprehensively equipped with the very latest scientific recording instruments. Sidney Ray, an authority on the languages of Oceania, the musicologist Dr. C.S. Myers and the naturalist Dr. C.G. Seligman used two wax-cylinder phonographs to make about one hundred records of Islander speech and song.[15] These survive in the British Institute of Recorded Sound. Their photographic kit included equipment for taking stills, movies and even experimental colour photographs by the Ives and Joly process. These would have been the earliest colour photographs taken in Australia.[16] The photography was done by Haddon and by a 21 year old student with previous experience in Algeria and Egypt, Anthony Wilkin, who died of dysentery in Cairo only three years later.[17] The psychologists and medical experts Dr. W.H.R. Rivers and Dr.W. McDougall completed the party.

They reached Thursday Island on 22 April 1898 and spent almost seven months in the Torres Strait and New Guinea. Four months were spent in the Murray Islands, whose inaccessibility and relatively undisturbed culture made them particularly suitable for study. Two visits were made there, the first during May 1898, the latter commencing on 20 July and concluding on the 8 September.[18]

Haddon's Films

In March 1898, Haddon purchased a 35 mm Newman and Guardia movie outfit in London, including 30 rolls of raw film 75 feet long, intending to reproduce Islander dances, ceremonies and customs.[19] The dispatch of the film was apparently delayed by being inadvertently sent to Haddon's friend, Mr. C. Hose, in Sarawak.[20] As a result, filming did not begin until the last week of their second stay on Murray Island, after 1 September 1898. Another problem was encountered with the Newman and Guardia movie camera, which sustained damage in transit, causing the films to jam in the tropical climate. Only a few films were taken successfully.

According to Haddon's diary,[21] the films were made by Haddon himself, possibly assisted by Anthony Wilkin:

5 September 1898: Tried to take cinematograph photo of fire making by Pasi, Sergeant and Mana [?] in morning.

6 September 1898: Tried to take cinematograph photos of Murray I.Kap in Australia corrobora (beche de mer men on board the lugger Coral Sea belonging Fred Lankester [...] Bomai-Malu cinematographed [?] at Kiam [...]
Haddon's journal covering the week of 1-8 September 1898, written while the expedition was packing for its departure from Murray Island, indicates that filming had only been a partial success:
[...] some rather important things turned up at the last [...] For example some Australian natives came in a beche de mer boat and I wanted to get a cinematograph of their dancing - and it was also only just at the last that we could get part of the Malu ceremony danced with the masks that had been made for me - but the dance was worth waiting for. I tried to cinematograph it but as has often happened the machine jams and the film is spoiled - I am afraid that this part of my outfit will prove a failure & the colour photograph is I fear at present of little practical value. I have had many disappointments on this expedition, perhaps I was too sanguine.

Thursday 8 September [1898] we left Murray Island [per the "Niue"] at 10 a.m.[...] [22]

Haddon's fears about his films were ill founded. On return to London, he had the few rolls shot on Murray Island processed by Newman and Guardia. Reporting on these on 28 June 1899, J.Guardia told him:

With respect to the Kinematograph, we are waiting for you to return the machine for repair, when we will report as to what has gone wrong with it. In the meantime, we beg to enclose a print from a strip of one of your films. We would submit that there is nothing much to complain of with a machine that produces work of this quality practically on the first trial and under admittedly unfavourable circumstances. We tested all the films, and have developed those that promise good results. We still have one or two more to finish.[23]
Although limited in both scope and duration, the surviving 4.5 minutes of Haddon's films continue to surprise modern audiences with their high technical standard. The material surviving matches the descriptions in Haddon's diary and journal, and there seems to be little missing from the print. Strangely, no screenings of the films by Haddon have been traced. The six volumes of Reports of the Cambridge Anthropological Expedition to Torres Straits, published between 1901 and 1935, contain virtually no mention of the films, other than a few frame enlargements (plate 29) in volume six. These show "the movements of the zogo le" (cult priests) from the Bomai-Malu ceremony, stated to have been shot at Kiam in the Eastern Torres Strait.[24]

Influence on Baldwin Spencer

On 23 October 1900, hearing of Spencer and Gillen's forthcoming expedition to Central Australia, Haddon wrote to Spencer:

You really must take a kinematograph - a biograph - or whatever they call it in your part of the world. It is an indispensable piece of anthropological apparatus. Get an ordinary commercial one. If you order from London I think I would place myself in the hands of the Warwick Trading Company, 4 Warwick Court, High Holborn W.C. I have asked them to send you a catalogue and to write to you as well. I have stated what you want it for. I have no doubt that your films will pay for the whole apparatus if you care to let some of them be copied by the trade.[25]

Examination of the Warwick Trading Company film catalogue for August 1901 reveals that Haddon may have allowed one of his films to be "copied by the trade" in the manner he suggested:

Cat. 6250b. Panorama of Thursday Island, the Headquarters of the Pearl Fishing Industry. This little know island is very difficult of access, but from it the great majority of the largest and finest pearls are obtained. The view presented in the film embraces the jetty alongside which the sailing craft are moved as they return from the fishing grounds. In the background the conformation of the island is distinctly seen, whilst as the camera rotates a number of pearling cutters are seen lying at anchor in the estuary. Length 75 feet [1 minute 15 seconds].

The film is not known to survive and the inclusion of the "pan" movement described is puzzling, as none of Haddon's known films show that he could "pan" to follow dancers' movements. However, Spencer was quick to follow Haddon's advice. On 1 December 1900, Spencer wrote to Haddon:

I am cabling home to the Warwick Co. to send me out the Biograph [sic] instrument. They wrote me by last mail saying that a catalogue was forwarded [...] I was in hopes that you would have given me some advice as to how much film to take with me as I have had no experience in this line and can get no help out here [in Melbourne].[26]

Spencer's work with the Warwick Bioscope in Central Australia during 1901 is well known.[27] Many popular histories credit him as being the pioneer of these techniques, ignoring the Torres Strait precedent. Haddon reaped more tangible rewards. In 1900, he was appointed University Lecturer in Ethnology at Cambridge University, and in 1901 was elected to a fellowship at Christ's College.[28]

Haddon's films were stored at Cambridge until 1967, when the British Film Institute copied them.[29] Prints are now held by the National Film & Sound Archive and AIATSIS in Canberra, and by Ian Dunlop at Film Australia in Lindfield. They are the oldest surviving Queensland films, and the oldest films of Torres Strait Islanders. As a result of the bêche de mer men's visit to Murray Island on 6 September 1898, they are also the oldest films of Australian Aborigines.

Haddon's Torres Strait Expedition Filmography


Notes

[Notes [1] - [12] relate to the earlier part of the text, not reproduced here]

[13] Ian Dunlop, "Ethnographic Film-Making in Australia - The First Seventy Years", in Aboriginal History 1979, 3:2. [back to text]

[14] Torres Straits Pilot, 19 March 1898, pp.2-3. A.C. Haddon Australian and Pacific Papers Indiex, National Library of Australia, 1991, p.i. [back to text]

[15] Alan Ward, "The Frazer Collection of Wax Cylinders: An Introduction", in Recorded Sound 85, Journal of the British Library National Sound Archive, January 1984, p.1. See also A.C. Haddon Papers, Cambridge University Library, envelope 1049. The two phonographs were an Edison "Home" and a Columbia "Bijou". [back to text]

[16] Earliest Australian colour photos were previously assumed to have been taken by Mark Blow in 1899. Refer Alan Davies, The Mechanical Eye in Australia, Oxford University Press, Melbourne, 1985, p.104. [back to text]

[17] A.C. Haddon, Headhunters: Black, White and Brown, Methuen, London, 1901. [back to text]

[18] Ibid. [back to text]

[19] A.C. Haddon Papers, Cambridge University Library, envelope 1049. Microfilm copy held at National Library of Australia, Canberra. [back to text]

[20] Information from Frances Calvert, Berlin [back to text]

[21] A.C. Haddon Papers, envelope 1055: Diary 10 March 1898-25 March 1899. [back to text]

[22] A.C. Haddon Papers, envelope 1030: Haddon's 1898 Journal [back to text]

[23] A.C. Haddon Papers, envelope 1049: J. Guardia to A.C. Haddon, 28 June 1899. [back to text]

[24] Reports of the Cambridge Anthropological Expedition to Torres Straits, Vol. 6, pp. 306-307. [back to text]

[25] W.B. Spencer Papers, Pitt Rivers Museum, Oxford University: Haddon to Spencer, 23 October 1900. Copy held by Ian Dunlop. [back to text]

[26] A.C. Haddon Papers, Box 1 envelope 3: Spencer to Haddon, 1 December 1900. [back to text]

[27] Ross Lansell and Peter Beilby, The Documentary Film in Australia, Cinema Papers, in association with Film Victoria, Melbourne, 1982, p.23. [back to text]

[28] A.C. Haddon Australian and Pacific Papers Index, National Library, Canberra, 1991, p.i. [back to text]

[29] British Film Institute catalogue card, "Torres Strait" (film), Haddon. 272 feet, 35 mm, from Cambridge Ethnographical Society, 1967. [back to text]


Further reading and films relating to the Torres Strait

from 1996 not updated

Works by A. C. Haddon:

Works about A. C. Haddon:

Works about the Torres Strait:

Films about the Torres Strait: